Transparent Review From An eBay Reseller

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Every reseller hits the point where they know that digging through rack after rack in thrift stores just isn’t going to cut it. For some people it’s because they’re just sick and tired of thrift stores. For others, it’s because they realize that they can never find enough inventory to make the kind of money they want to make.

At that point, you have a couple of different options. You can just accept that your reselling business will never be super profitable, you can quit, or you can change your methods in a way that will allow you to scale your business. Which leads most people to the same question: how can I get massive amounts of inventory with less of a time investment?

The answer, of course, is to buy items in bulk. Unless you want to set-up wholesale accounts and pivot your business into selling new items, you probably started looking at buying customer returns and other types of liquidation. Personally, I suffer from thrift store burnout in waves but the real reason I wanted to buy liquidation pallets was to grow a massive eBay store that would be more than a basic full-time income.

For most people, is one of the first sites they come across when looking for inventory in bulk or the ever-popular (and overpriced) “pallets of Amazon returns.” One of the main reasons for this is because advertises aggressively, not to mention the fact that they are one of the biggest companies in the space, having done over 8 billion dollars in sales with over 3.6 million buyers.

However, has a less than stellar reputation in most online communities and reseller circles. Despite having heard dozens of horror stories about the platform we continue to buy from regularly. So with that in mind, I figured I’d share with you the reality buying not only from but from liquidation sites in general. If you don’t know that you’re doing, you’ll likely lose all the money you invest and become one of the bitter people leaving them a nasty review on ConsumerAffairs.

How Does Work?

If you sell on eBay or Poshmark it should be easy to understand how works. They simply do the same thing as the platforms you know but at a much higher level. They provide a platform where sellers and stores can list items for sale in bulk. Typically these items are lots ranging in size from a box of product to a truckload.

Just like eBay or Poshmark, charges a percentage fee to sell something on their service. In addition to providing a platform, however, they also provide warehouses where they store and ship the merchandise as well as handle all payments.

It’s important to remember that it’s not selling the lots you bid on. Just as it’s not 100% eBay’s fault if you deal with a crappy seller on their platform it’s not’s fault if the lot you buy ends up being garbage. And it happens.

It’s also worth noting that most of the auctions on are not actually from stores or manufactureres. They are listing from other resellers who buy direct from the stores and then resell to you. In some instances you might be 2-3 middlemen away from the primary source of the product. With every middleman the products get cherrypicked (eg. they get crappier) and they get a bit more expensive.

As an example, Amazon does not sell pallets of returns directly on, depsite the staggering number of Amazon returns available on there. There are high level resellers who buy truckloads (or several truckloads) of products from Amazon and then break them up into smaller lots to sell to you and I (often after pulling some of the best/easiest to resell items).

So why would you buy from

The main reason to buy from is simply to get your feet wet in the bulk-buying industry. It’s not the most profitable platform. However, until you have the experience to feel confident spending tens of thousands of dollars on truckloads of product, it’s probably your best bet.

The other reason to buy from the is that, despite their repuation, they are a large and legitimate company that provides some level of professionalism and protection for buyers. Can you get scammed? Yes, but it’s less likely than on sketchier platforms and far less likely if you are aware of what you’re doing.

My Experiences on

In the past two years I’ve spent over $5,000 (not including shipping) on and purchased around 30 lots of every type imaginable. It should be fairly obvious that they are not our only source of inventory. We use other bulk sources and still thrift regularly.

During that time, I have had 3 orders that were absolute trash. They were all items that were sold as “customer returns” but everything inside was smashed or otherwise unusable. I ended up selling the best items for parts and sending the rest to the dump as it wasn’t even worth donating. I didn’t quite make my money back. Apart from those orders, however, I have profited on every lot I’ve bought.

For the first 10 lots I bought I kept absolutely meticulous records. Most eBay sellers have absolutely no idea how much money they actually make and I firmly believe most make way less than they think. Here’s an idea of what the first lot I bought looked like: review excel sheet value example

Our Average Liquidation Lot

Most people claim that “the best you can do is double your money” on liquidation and it’s close to the truth. While we have had some boxes that were gold-mines, we haven’t made 10x our money like you can at a thrift store. Our average return has been somewhere before 2-3x.

Even in the best lots you can expect to find a significant amount of things that are broken, missing parts, or not worth selling for other reasons. On average, we end up donating or throwing away between 10-30% of each lot. The rest is typically sellable in some form or another.

I guess the most telling aspect of my expereincew is that I’ve continued to buy from their platform. I’ve learned a couple good sellers that I trust and simply stick to their auctions, no matter how shiny something else looks.

So if I were give a review in a couple of sentences it would go something like this: is a legitimate platform for buying returns, shelf pulls, and salvage items. Once you gain some experience on the platform it is possible to consistently make 2-3x your money flipping items you buy.

No exactly glowing, is it? Well, that about sums up my experience.

Why does have such terrible reviews?

When I first contemplated buying large lots, I read all of the reviews I could find. In general, the angry and critical reviews could be summed up with one sentance:

People were shocked and angry at the quality of the products they recieved.

The problem here is two-fold. Yes, sometimes when you buy liquidation lots (from any site) you will get screwed. That is part of the game. This is the reason why you should never spend money that you can’t afford to lose on returns or liquidation. Yes, it does suck to spend a ton of time breaking down a pallet and selling it to simply recoup your investment. But sometimes you win big as well.

Now the other part of the issue is the part I think it the “real” issue: people think they’ve discovered a gold-mine and bid big on an auction. They assume the best about the product and are severely let down to find out they overpaid.

If you think you’re going to get a lot of perfectly working electronics and sell them for 80% of the claimed MSRP you’re going to be a very sad reseller. Remember, things are being liquidated for a reason. If there was abundant easy money in it, it wouldn’t be liquidated or margins would be even thinner. Expect the absolute worst in a lot and you’ll usually be mildly happy with it.

Best Sellers

Long story short, I cannot recommend any of the smaller sellers on the platform. This isn’t to say that they’re not any good, I just haven’t used them. I do bid on the odd clothing lot but, in general, I limit my purchases to the companies I know to source their goods from Amazon. At the risk of driving up prices for myself, you can find a search with all of the sellers that I buy from here.

Now, that’s not to say that everything they sell is good or profitable. You’ll have to use your judgment.

Things to Keep in Mind?

I had a bunch of thoughts and tips for buying on that I couldn’t quite fit into the article. Because I think they’re important I just decided to list them here for you:

  1. Do not buy electronics from electronics companies. This should be self-evident but many of the angry reviews I see are from people who buy things like iPhones and find out that they’re all trash. Think for a second, if they were any good, the company would have sold them themselves like they do all the other working phones. This applies to pretty much every “refurbished” item on the site as well as many of them are items that the sellers tried and failed to fix.
  2. You will get screwed on shipping. makes money on shipping so don’t expect to pay a fair price.
  3. You’re bidding against people who can pick up auctions. We typically buy lots that are located in Las Vegas as that the closest center to us (meaning the cheapest shipping). However, we have thin margins because most people bidding on those lots plan to pick them up in person and don’t have to factor shipping into their costs. We actually bought a 15 passenger van and drove the 13 hours roundtrip to Vegas to pick up a ground of 6 lots and came out money ahead.
  4. Don’t spend money you can’t afford to lose. With every lot you buy, it’s totally possible that you get hosed. Buying liquidation pallets takes capital so, if you’re short on funds, stick to thrifting and the Goodwill Outlet until you have some cash reserves and could take a loss.
  5. The bigger the lots, the better the deal. The more money you’re willing to invest, the better chance you have of getting a deal. The farther up the money food-chain you go the fewers buyers you’ll find.
  6. Don’t buy a pallet or lot based on a single item. Often times you’ll find lots of trash that have one or two good items in them. Typically, the seller has added an item to sweeten the deal and get some boxes of crap out of their warehouse. The chances of that one item being defective are as good as any other so don’t bid. Look for auctions where, even if the top items were trash, you could still come out ahead.
  7. Electronics are the most overpriced area. In fact, I rarely buy electronics. They often go for up to 30% of MSRP (or more) leaving very little room for profit. Unless you have the expertise to fix broken electronics yourself to try and coax every last dollar out of a lot I’d pass.
  8. Distrust the MSRP and study the manifests. Before bidding on my first lots I looked up almost every single item on the manifest to see what I could actually sell it for. Some things sell for more than they state, nearly everything sells for less. It’s not uncommon to find a lot of clothing with an MSRP of $4,000 only to find out that all of the clothing in it already failed to sell on clearance at Nordstrom Rack for 90% off of retail.
  9. Companies misrepresent their products. While this is less true of the high volume sellers (such as the ones I linked above) most small sellers will be deceptive or outright lie to you about what they’re selling. For example, you might find a title that says something like “iPad Pro 128GB (Quantity: 30)” but when you look at the manifest you find out that you’re getting only one iPad Pro and 29 first-generation 16GB iPads. Do your due diligence.
  10. Everything is sold “as is”. does have a dispute system but it’s not very user-friendly. You are limited by some very specific requirements and time windows. I’ve never bothered filing a dispute. It’s easier for me to chalk it up to a learning experience and move on, knowing that it’ll lower my tax bill at the end of the year.
  11. Avoid lots with a high MSRP but a low individual item value. You will find lots on that have an MSRP of over $2,000 but contain several hundred items. Of the working ones, you’ll be lucky to sell them for 50-75% of retail, meaning $10 a pop. If high volume low dollar sales fit with your business model, go for it. They don’t fit with mine.

Final Review and Thoughts

Perhaps the best thing that has done is provide a platform that is accessible to resellers who just want to get their feet wet buying pallet and returns. If you can’t afford to buy items by the truck-load, it can be a great place to get some experience and make some money.

As long as you have tempered your expectations and go about things in an intelligent way, you don’t have to worry about losing the farm.


If isn’t a great fit for you, there are several other reputable sellers that work with stores to liquidate their returns and overstock. I have not used all of these so do some research before jumping in!

Whichever liquidation company you choose to buy from, be smart, have fun, and may the odds always be in your financial favor!

Other Articles You’ll Enjoy

Leave a Comment